If you’ve just sent a child to kindergarten this year you probably know how difficult a decision it can be. Is your son or daughter ready? Will she be the youngest in the class? So many factors to consider. Many schools have mandatory cut-off dates, based on your child’s birthday, which makes the decision so much easier.
According to a recent article in the New York Times, apparently parents are using a wide range of factors for making the decision. Reasons cited ranged from being tall enough to play high school sports to emotional maturity. The story’s title even contains the word “Redshirting” which is the practice of holding a high school athlete back for the sake of competitive sports. It never dawned on me to think about high school sports! But, it’s a new world.
Kindergarten is not the same experience of my childhood or even my children’s time, 20-some years ago. We’ve become so competitive in today’s society that even this earliest of school experiences is fraught with competition and the need to excel. Five year olds are expected to be competitive and possess significant skills upon entering school. It’s hard to imagine a kindergarten teacher telling a parent that his child lacks the necessary math skills… isn’t that what they’re coming to school to learn? The term “early education” has changed to include infants, we are trying to educate our children at a much earlier age than in any other time in recent history. Is that a good thing?
So, how do we decide if a 5 year old is ready to enter kindergarten? Is is based on emotional maturity? Or is it more important that they be as tall as the others in the class? Someone will always be the shortest and the youngest. There are so many factors to consider, and putting a child in school before he’s ready can be traumatic if it means later having to repeat a school year.
It’s not an absolute science. We all mature at different rates, what works for one child with an August birthday may not work for another with the exact same date. Factors like shyness, size, fine motor skills all come into play.
I’m not sure why we have arrived at a place where children are pushed to excel at such an early age? What’s the rush? They’ve got years and years to achieve. I’m in favor of keeping children children. Having fun, exploring, playing and getting to know themselves without all the pressure.
What do you think? Is this a decision you’ve had to grapple with?
Connect with Little Butterfly Kiss website, blog, Twitter, or Facebook




